Most employers want a benefits package that helps them hire and keep people without blowing the budget. Competitive does not mean matching what large tech companies offer. It means your package looks reasonable next to other employers of similar size, industry, and location who are recruiting the same people.
For a New York or New Jersey company with 15–150 employees, that benchmark is usually other regional firms, not national headquarters with stock options and unlimited PTO. The goal is a package people notice during offer negotiations and do not complain about at renewal.
Start with the core medical decision
Medical coverage is the largest line and the one candidates ask about first. Decide the deductible level, the network, and whether you will offer an HSA-qualified high-deductible plan before you add anything else.
KFF’s 2025 Employer Health Benefits Survey showed average annual premiums of roughly $9,325 for single coverage and $26,993 for family coverage across all firms. At smaller firms (10–199 employees), family premiums were similar, but workers often paid a higher share of the family premium. Many small employers cover a larger portion of the employee-only premium and less for dependents. That structure is common because it keeps the employer’s cost more predictable while still giving the employee meaningful coverage.
Once medical is set, most packages add dental and vision (often fully or mostly employee-paid), basic life and short-term disability (low cost relative to medical), and a pharmacy benefit that rides with the medical plan. Prescription costs have risen with specialty drugs and broader use of certain medications, so the pharmacy design and formulary matter at renewal even if they look secondary during initial setup. For more on controlling rising medical costs, see our post on what employers can control in 2026.
Contribution strategy shapes both cost and perception
Employers typically choose between a percentage of premium or a flat dollar amount. A percentage (for example, 75% of the employee-only premium) scales automatically if rates rise. A flat dollar amount stays fixed until you change it, which can make budgeting easier but can leave employees covering a larger share after a rate increase.
Many small employers land between 50% and 80% of the employee-only premium, with lower percentages or flat amounts for dependents. Carriers often require a minimum employer contribution (commonly around 50% of the employee-only rate) and a participation floor to issue a group policy. Below those thresholds, the case may not quote or may price higher.
For HSA-qualified plans, an employer contribution to the HSA can offset the higher deductible. KFF data has shown average employer HSA contributions in the hundreds of dollars for single coverage among firms that contribute. Some employers contribute nothing and simply offer the plan; others seed a few hundred dollars or more. The contribution counts toward the annual HSA limit, so employees need to know the remaining room for their own deposits. 2026 HSA limits are $4,400 for self-only and $8,750 for family coverage (plus $1,000 catch-up at age 55+).
Employee premium contributions are almost always more attractive when run pretax through a Section 125 cafeteria plan. This does not reduce the employer’s gross premium cost, but it improves the net cost for employees and can improve take-up.
Cost levers that preserve the offer
You can lower the premium without stripping the package down to something candidates reject. Common levers include moving from a richer network or plan design to a tighter network or higher deductible while pairing it with an HSA contribution or lower employee premium share. Reviewing the pharmacy benefit at renewal for formulary and specialty drug management options also helps. Shopping multiple carriers or asking the current carrier for a competitive offer is practical at renewal because mid-year changes are harder for both administration and employee communication.
These changes work best when you model the effect on both the employer’s total spend and the employee’s out-of-pocket exposure. A lower premium that pairs with a much higher deductible can look cheaper on paper and still generate complaints if employees hit the deductible early in the year. Our earlier piece on group health insurance for small businesses covers related cost-saving approaches.
How to judge whether the package is good enough
Ask a few concrete questions rather than looking for a universal “good” package:
- How does your employee premium share and deductible compare with similar-size employers in your industry and metro area?
- Are candidates or current employees regularly raising medical coverage as a reason they take or leave a job?
- At the last renewal, did you receive competitive quotes, or did the carrier’s increase go through with limited pushback?
- Do you know the approximate employer cost per enrolled employee for medical, and is that cost rising faster than your revenue or wage budget?
If the answers are “we do not know” or “yes, people mention it,” the package is probably not yet competitive relative to your market. Benchmarks from KFF and carrier proposals give the external reference points. Internal feedback from recruiting and exit conversations gives the local signal.
When a benefits broker helps
A broker’s practical value usually shows up in three places: market checks at renewal, plan design options that balance cost and coverage, and compliance tracking for ACA, ERISA, COBRA or state continuation rules, and Section 125 administration. For New York and New Jersey employers, state rules on paid leave, disability, and continuation coverage add another layer that varies by headcount and funding type.
Brokers who work with small and mid-size groups can usually obtain quotes from multiple carriers and translate the options into numbers an owner or CFO can compare. The work is less about inventing a unique package and more about running the renewal process so the employer sees the trade-offs before the rates lock in. Timing the work around open enrollment planning keeps communication and enrollment smoother.
Want a second set of eyes on your current package or upcoming renewal? Get a free benefits analysis.
Leave a Reply